Stephen Duncombe writes in the premier issue of Turbulence, a new theoretical journal-cum-newspaper that:
The problem, as I see it, comes down to reality.
Progressives believe in it, Bush’s people believe in creating it. The
left and right have switched roles – the right taking on the mantle of
radicalism and progressives waving the flag of conservatism. The
political progeny of the protestors who proclaimed, “Take your desires
for reality” in May of 1968, were now counseling the reversal: take
reality for your desires. Republicans were the ones proclaiming, “I
have a dream.”
I have to say I know what he's talking about. From defending the evaporating, fetid gains of the welfare state or the ongoing acceptance by people who should know better of the Clintonian urge to do the Bushie thing right, large sectors of the "left" have become more conservative than those they ostensibly oppose. The fault of this, if where it lies is so simple, may reside less in a lack of the urge to dream than in the inculcated, now naturalized habits of American anti-communism – those who refuse to even say the world socialism shouldn't be shocked when the movements they lead and participate in settle for a refracted politics of fear and permanent, if glorious, resistance. After all, isn't "yelling from the mountaintop" just another word for vanguardism? Or, is it only a dread vanguard when there's the expectation that people will listen, be transformed and themselves take responsibility for others?
I only ask these questions because it seems like the stalemate in the movement of movements has settled into a discomforting middle age. One quick note: Turbulence makes it's entire issues immediately available as a PDF. In other words, they write so that people read! Here's to hoping more publications see the wisdom in this. Click on the cover to get the entire issue as a PDF formatted for letter-size paper.